Feedback Post

[slashmarks]

Now that the exchange is complete, I'd like to hear your opinions on what went well and anything you think might be better changed in the future.

Some subjects I'm particularly interested in:

-Did the ratings matching help you? Was it confusing? Would you like to have ratings matching, but change how it works?

-I'm considering a no modern RPF rule next round. How do people feel about this idea?

-Were the freeforms helpful? Would you like to add, remove or rearrange any freeform tags?

-Anything else you feel strongly about!

Comments

[theodwulf]

-Did the ratings matching help you? Was it confusing? Would you like to have ratings matching, but change how it works?

I'm not sure the teen distinction works for the gore part, but I'm also not sure how many people even asked for it.

-I'm considering a no modern RPF rule next round. How do people feel about this idea?

I don't write this, but I think the suggestions above make sense ie no under 18 or RL serial killers. I definitely think there needs to be a distinction between the actual person and a role they play, given how terrible AO3 is right now about some fandoms where that's not clear IE basically any gaming youtube fandom where the wranglers refuse to canonize anything but the real-life name.

-Were the freeforms helpful? Would you like to add, remove or rearrange any freeform tags?

Freeforms are great! It might be nice to open the tags up to allow for participants to submit suggestions, like Consent Issues / Id Pro Quo / etc do, but I don't know how much work that is on the back end.

-Anything else you feel strongly about!

The schedule was good, I'm glad it opened on a Friday and not in the middle of the week. You might bump the minimum to 1k.